Plan Sponsor Council of America Report: 2017 Annual Survey of Profit Sharing and 401(k) Plans

The Executive Director of PSCA, Jack Towarnicky, addressed a workshop at the April NAPA
401(k) Summit, reporting on the findings of their 2017 survey focusing on the impacts of autoenrollment
and auto-escalation features.

Towarnicky reported that auto-enrollments have virtually doubled since implementation –
rising to 63% in 2016, from 32% in 2007. However, participation has held steady at
approximately 85%. Although 60% of DC plans use automatic features, 42% use
nondiscrimination safe harbors. He stated that clearly, while workers are saving, not many are
saving enough. A possible cause for the 85% participation rate, according to the survey, is that
85% of plans that implemented auto-enrollments limit this to new hires.

Additional survey results found that plans with a default deferral over 3%, rose to over 53% in
2016, from 32% in 2011, and over 73% of plans now include an auto-escalation feature.

The ASPPA article of April 18, 2018, indicated that this workshop used an instant polling
smartphone-based app to measure the adoption of auto features and Roth contribution
defaults by attendees’ clients, showing the results immediately. Questions and responses were:

Percentage of your clients who have adopted one or more automatic features:
None 6%
1-24% 43%
25-49% 31%
50-74% 11%
75-99% 8%
100% 0%

For your clients who have adopted automatic enrollment, what is the mode or most frequent
default contribution percentage?
<3% 3%
3 57%
4% 15%
5% 13%
6% 10%
>6% 3%

For your clients who have adopted automatic enrollment, how many use a Roth 401(k)
contribution default (not pre-tax)?
90+% None
75-89% 3%
50-74% None
25-49% None
10-24% 3%
1-9% 7%
None 87%

Doug Prince, CEO of ProCourse Fiduciary Advisors, LLC, who co-moderated this workshop
indicated that he believes auto-enrollment has caused a lack of properly executed beneficiary
designations following a participant’s death. He suggested that “auto-beneficiary designation”
might be an issue to address next. Towarnicky added that a default solution could work if no
valid beneficiary designation is on file.

Related Posts

Sticky Post

Deadline to Adopt a Plan Extended Under SECURE Act

The SECURE Act was signed into law at the end of 2019. Among its many provisions was the ability to...
Sticky Post

Happy Thanksgiving!

Economic Group Pension Services, Inc. would like to wish you and your family a healthy and happy Thanksgiving! Gratitude is...